Even though encryption is only beginning to roll out to people who sign up for the public beta for Android Messages, turning on encryption for RCS is a very big deal. It’s a massive privacy win, as it could mean that the de facto replacement for SMS will, by default, be private on the smartphone platform used by the vast majority of people worldwide.As for the people who use that other smartphone platform — the iPhone — we have no word on whether Apple intends to adopt the RCS standard. But as every carrier worldwide gets on board, and now that there is a clearer path to ensuring private communication with RCS, the pressure on Apple to participate is likely to build.
Unfortunately, SMS becoming fully deprecated and replaced by RCS will only happen if all goes to plan for Google. Since initially announcing plans to transition to RCS as the primary texting platform for Android, the standard’s rollout has been mired in confusion. In attempting to be neutral and make Android’s texting a standard shared by carriers worldwide, Google set itself up with the job of herding multibillion-dollar cats — with sadly predictable results. However, last year, Google began to take matters into its own hands, slowly letting users in different countries get RCS services directly from Google rather than wait for their carrier to turn it on. (Even when carriers did turn it on, it has often not been interoperable.)
Today, the company has announced that process is complete and RCS is available through Android Messages everywhere Google offers its services (i.e., not China). In certain regions and with certain carriers, Google will continue to allow those carriers to run your RCS services if they so choose.
Worldwide availability is an important milestone, but to me, the fact that Google is building on top of RCS to eventually make Android Messages end-to-end encrypted by default is the much bigger news. So let’s get into how exactly it will work because there are some things to be aware of.
First, as mentioned, it will be rolling out in beta this month, and Google has no timeline for when encrypted chats will graduate into the main app. And as for people willing to sign up for the public beta of Android Messages, be aware that, as usual, Google will be rolling out the feature gradually, so you might not get it right away.
End-to-end encryption will only work on one-on-one chats when both users are using Android Messages and have received the update. Enabling end-to-end encryption on group chats is a much trickier problem, so Google won’t commit to a timeline for extending the feature.Android Messages on the web is simply a portal to the messaging app on your phone, so just like Signal and WhatsApp, texts you send in that interface will also be encrypted. Speaking of Signal, Google has selected the Signal Protocol for its encryption implementation — just like WhatsApp. (The Signal Protocol is simply the code used to secure the messages; it does not mean those apps can interoperate.)
If you are texting with somebody who isn’t using Android Messages (say, somebody using Samsung Messages or an iPhone), the fallback to either less-encrypted RCS chat or SMS will still work just fine. And since Android Messages’ more advanced features are all built into the app instead of living in the cloud, turning on encryption shouldn’t break any other app experiences.The saga of getting carriers and various other business interests aligned on an RCS standard is ongoing. That standard is called the Universal Profile, and it is still evolving as I write this. One thing that isn’t part of the Universal Profile is the encryption standard Google is adopting. It’s building it on top of RCS right into the Android Messages client.
But while another company with questionable privacy practices Facebook occupies the social level of human behavior, Google with its Search can reach the deepest personal layers of a person.Step 2: Go to the to use the new Google Takeout feature.Be aware that extracting your data and deleting it are two different processes.
That doesn’t mean Google intends for its encryption solution to be proprietary. The company tells me it would be happy to work with any company to work on compatibility. Google has published a brief technical paper available that provides a high-level overview of Google’s method for encryption in Android Messages. In other words, it may well be that Google’s encryption implementation could someday become part of the Universal Profile standard. As with Apple, there could be some pressure put on the GSMA (the carrier consortium) to move toward more encryption. Facebook still intends to make all of its messaging apps encrypted by default, so it is increasingly becoming a norm for texting. (Disclosure: my wife works for Facebook Reality Labs, the AR / VR division of the company. Read my full ethics statement here.)
As with all things RCS, it’s better to think of today’s announcements as part of an evolving process rather than a launch. Many things in tech have big, splashy moments where products become immediately available and start having an impact right away. RCS is not one of those things.
Update, 10:25 am ET, Nov 19: Google has released the technical paper on how it has implemented encryption already, instead of later this month as expected. We have also added a link to the availability map, which shows that both China and Russia are excluded. The article has been updated to reflect that.
Does Google Maps Have Privacy Issues?